January 8, 2012

New York antitrust trial begins over credit cards’ forced arbitrations

Three of the largest U.S. credit card issuers headed to trial on Monday to defend accusations that they colluded to force customers to agree to settle disputes through arbitration rather than in class-action lawsuits.

American Express Co., Discover Financial Services and Citigroup Inc. face the allegations in two antitrust lawsuits filed by customers who had to sign arbitration agreements in order to get credit cards.

U.S. District Judge William Pauley in Manhattan is hearing the cases without a jury.

The trial follows a landmark U.S. Supreme Court decision in 2011. That case involved an AT&T Inc. unit, and bolstered corporations’ ability to require customers to arbitrate disputes over fees or other issues.

Arbitration puts more costs and burdens on individuals than if they collectively pursued claims in class actions, consumer advocates say.

No damages are being sought in the antitrust lawsuits, which were filed in 2004 and 2005, and consolidated for trial before Judge Pauley in March.

Instead, the plaintiffs are asking the judge to order American Express, Discover and Citigroup to remove arbitration clauses from their cardholder agreements.

The plaintiffs also want an eight-year ban on arbitration clauses by the trio, which had 31.4 per cent of outstanding credit card balances in 2011, according to The Nilson Report, a payment card industry newsletter.

In the first day of testimony on Monday, lead plaintiff Robert Ross from Pennsylvania said he did not view arbitration as a “fair venue” for consumers.

“If the average consumer was aware of the costs they’d have to bear in arbitration, they wouldn’t do it,” Mr. Ross said in response to questioning by a lawyer for American Express, Rowan Wilson of Cravath, Swaine & Moore.

Lawyers for the plaintiffs will present evidence that big banks in 28 meetings from 1999 to 2003 discussed how to institute mandatory arbitration clauses, court documents show.

Within three years, all the banks imposed almost identical arbitration clauses that prevented cardholders from pursuing class actions, the plaintiffs claim.

Citigroup, Discover and American Express assert that they adopted the arbitration agreements independently.

They also contend that the plaintiffs have failed to show that arbitration clauses curb competition or cause injury under federal antitrust law.

“We include arbitration in our card-member agreements because we think that it is an important part of American Express’s overall approach to resolving any disputes with its card members quickly and efficiently,” American Express representative Marina Hoffmann Norville told Reuters.

Representatives for Discover and Citigroup declined to comment.

Four other banks – JPMorgan Chase & Co., Bank of America Corp., HSBC Holdings PLC and Capital One Financial Corp. – settled claims in one of the lawsuits against them in 2010 by removing the arbitration clauses from their cardholder agreements for 3-1/2 years.

Those banks also agreed to pay the plaintiffs’ lawyers $2.35-million in fees and expenses.

Following those settlements, outstanding credit card loans subject to arbitration clauses plunged from 95.1 per cent at the end of 2009 to 48 per cent a year later, according to a paper released in November by Peter Rutledge of University of Georgia School of Law and Christopher Drahozal at University of Kansas School of Law.

The settlements with the four banks are set to expire later this year, allowing them to again mandate arbitration.


The above statements do not represent those of Weston Legal or Michael Weston and they have not been reviewed for accuracy. The statements have been published by a third party and are being linked to by our website only because they contain information relating to debt. Nothing in this article should be construed as legal advice given by Weston Legal or Michael Weston. To view the source of the article, please following the link to the website that published the article. Articles written by Michael W. Weston can be viewed here: To report any problem with this article please email



5001 Bissonnet,
Suite 200
Bellaire, Texas 77401

Phone 713.623.4242
Fax 866-579-6411
Principal Office
Email Email
9901 I.H. 10 West
Suite 800
San Antonio, Texas 78230

Phone 210.787.3539
Fax 866-579-6411
by appointment only
Email Email
106 E. Sixth Street
Suite 900
Austin, Texas 78701

Phone 512.782.4377
Fax 866-579-6411
by appointment only
Email Email
320 Decker Drive ,
Suite 100
Dallas, Texas 75062

Phone 214.329.9837
Fax 866-579-6411
by appointment only
Email Email






2202 N West Shore Blvd,
Ste 200
Tampa, FL 33607

Phone 813.227.4965
Fax 866-579-6411
by appointment only
Email Email
841 Prudential Drive,
12th Floor
Jacksonville, FL 32207

Phone 904.380.6922
Fax 866-579-6411
by appointment only
Email Email
618 East South Street
Ste 500
Orlando, FL 32801

Phone 407.241.2380
by appointment only
Email Email
1111 Brickell Avenue
Miami, FL

Phone 305.913.3725
Fax 866-579-6411
by appointment only
Email Email




2375 East Camelback Road
Suite 600
Phoenix, Arizona 85016

Phone 602.308.0300
Fax 866-579-6411
by appointment only
Email Email